Get Permission Varshney, Thakor, Patel, and Chauhan: Contact lens adoption and associated knowledge among the general population of South Gujarat, India


Introduction

Refractive errors are common visual impairments that affect the eye's ability to focus light accurately on the retina, resulting in conditions such as myopia, hyperopia, and astigmatism. Spectacles have long been the dominant method for correcting these errors, providing effective improvement in visual performance. 1 However, contact lenses have become a popular alternative, offering advantages such as enhanced cosmetic appeal and an improved quality of life, especially for individuals who find spectacles limiting or undesirable.2 Contact lenses, whether corrective, cosmetic, or therapeutic, are placed directly on the cornea, providing clearer vision without the bulk of glasses. These lenses allow for a wider field of view, less image distortion, and increased comfort for users engaged in sports or physical activities.3

The global prevalence of contact lens use has increased significantly in recent decades. For example, a population-based survey in the United States revealed that approximately 4.9 million people opted for contact lenses. 4, 5, 6 Similarly, in the United Kingdom, the number of contact lens wearers rose from 1.6 million in 1992 to 3.7 million by 2016. 7 Countries such as Saudi Arabia, the USA, and Japan have also seen substantial increases in contact lens adoption, with prevalence rates ranging from 17% to 70%. 7

Despite their benefits, contact lenses present challenges related to hygiene and maintenance, which, if not adequately managed, can lead to complications such as microbial keratitis and other infections. Research indicates that up to 80% of complications arising from contact lens use are attributed to poor compliance with recommended care guidelines. 8 Inadequate hygiene, such as failure to clean lenses properly or improper storage, can introduce microbial contaminants that lead to severe conditions affecting the cornea.9 These risks are exacerbated in tropical climates, where environmental factors encourage microbial growth. Therefore, the need for proper evaluation, education, and regular follow-up for contact lens users is critical. 10

While there is considerable awareness regarding the use of spectacles, studies have shown resistance among spectacle wearers to switch to contact lenses due to concerns about hygiene and potential complications. Overcoming this resistance requires targeted educational efforts that address these concerns, encourage proper lens care, and dispel misconceptions. 11 In regions like Pakistan, where unique climatic and cultural factors may pose additional challenges, the need for tailored research into contact lens adoption and care practices is particularly urgent. 5 By focusing on these under-researched regions, this study aims to highlight the critical gaps in understanding the barriers to contact lens usage and provide recommendations for enhancing awareness and adherence to safe lens practices.

This study seeks to assess the general population's awareness and knowledge regarding contact lens use, with a focus on identifying knowledge gaps and promoting better practices to prevent complications. With technological advancements in contact lens materials and designs, there is an increasing need to ensure that users are equipped with the knowledge required to use them safely and effectively. Understanding these factors will contribute to reducing the burden of contact lens-related complications and improving overall ocular health.

Materials and Methods

This cross-sectional study was conducted using a structured questionnaire to assess public awareness, knowledge, and practices related to CL use.

A validated, structured online questionnaire was used. The questionnaire comprised both open-ended and closed-ended questions, covering demographics, awareness of CL types, hygiene practices, usage patterns, and knowledge of potential complications.

A total of 1,500 participants were recruited from the general population of South Gujarat, India. Participants varied in age, gender, and educational levels. Recruitment was done via online platforms, and informed consent was obtained from all participants.

Questionnaire content

  1. Demographics: Age, gender, education, occupation, and marital status.

  2. Awareness: General knowledge of contact lenses, reasons for use, and knowledge of CL types.

  3. Attitudes and Preferences: Comfort levels with CLs, concerns about risks, and brand preferences.

  4. Knowledge and Practices: Understanding of hygiene practices, cleaning routines, and complications.

  5. Usage Patterns: Frequency of use, duration of wear, and replacement schedules.

The questionnaire was administered via Google Forms between August 2023 and May 2024. All responses were recorded electronically, and data were stored securely.

Data were analyzed using SPSS software, and chi-square tests were used to assess the statistical significance of key findings. Results were presented as percentages, and p-values < 0.05 were considered significant.

Ethical approval was obtained from the institutional review board, and confidentiality was maintained for all participants.

Results

Demographic data

Of the 1,500 participants, 920 (61%) were female, and 580 (39%) were male (Table 1). The age distribution showed a significant skew toward younger individuals, with 79% of participants aged between 18-24 years (Table 2). This suggests a preference for contact lenses among younger demographics, possibly due to aesthetic appeal and independence from spectacles​. To assess the statistical significance of the observed gender distribution, a chi-square test was conducted. The results indicate that the observed distribution is significantly different from a uniform distribution (Chi-square: 287.04, p-value < 2.2e-16). This suggests that there is a statistically significant difference in the proportion of males and females in the sample.

General awareness of contact lenses

A majority of participants (60%) demonstrated general awareness of contact lenses, although only 30% could be classified as "extremely aware." This highlights a gap in knowledge that underscores the need for more targeted educational campaigns, particularly to inform the public about the benefits, uses, and proper care of contact lenses (Figure 1).

Figure 1

Awareness levels about contact lens uses

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/4ce6dc33-bb41-4144-8159-954916ed7010/image/3c480310-a1a2-40b6-aee9-187d109a7f5a-uimage.png

Contact lens usage purposes

Contact lenses were recognized for their versatility by 65% of participants, primarily for vision correction, followed by cosmetic and prosthetic applications. This emphasizes the multi-functional appeal of contact lenses, though a more detailed understanding of their therapeutic applications remains limited among the general population.

Familiarity with contact lens materials and designs

Despite the widespread use of contact lenses, nearly half of the participants (49%) were unaware of different lens materials and designs. Among those familiar with lens types, soft silicone hydrogel lenses were the most common, followed by soft hydrogel lenses, with rigid gas permeable (RGP) lenses being less prevalent. This gap in knowledge may contribute to improper selection and usage, potentially leading to complications (Table 3).

Contact lens brands and solutions

Bausch & Lomb and Johnson & Johnson emerged as the most popular brands among users, with Biotrue being the preferred solution for lens care. However, a significant portion of participants (42%) were either not using contact lenses or were unaware of available solutions, indicating limited market penetration or inadequate information about options(Table 3).

Wearing modality and duration

Participants exhibited a range of lens-wearing patterns. Daily disposable lenses were used by 16%, while weekly, bi-weekly, and monthly lenses were chosen by 11%, 6%, and 18%, respectively. Furthermore, 8% of users opted for extended wear lenses. The duration of contact lens use also varied, with 28% having used lenses for less than six months, and only 6% reporting usage for over two years.

Hygiene practices and awareness of side effects

Adherence to proper hygiene varied. While 66% of participants consistently removed their lenses before sleeping and 57% before swimming, only 43% were highly aware of the potential side effects associated with improper lens care. This discrepancy indicates a need for better education regarding both hygiene practices and the risks of complications, such as microbial infections.

Contact lens-related symptoms

Despite the high level of overall satisfaction reported by 80% of participants, 21% experienced some form of discomfort, including dryness and irritation. These symptoms suggest that fitting, material selection, and care routines require closer attention to prevent dropout due to discomfort. In fact, 28% of participants discontinued lens use within six months, highlighting the need for improved guidance on proper lens care and usage.

Discussion

This study provides valuable insights into the awareness, practices, and experiences of contact lens users in South Gujarat, India. Investigating contact lens awareness, usage patterns, and care practices among 1500 participants, the findings offer valuable insights for eye care professionals, contact lens manufacturers, and health educators.

The study found a significant skew towards younger adults (79% aged 18-24) using contact lenses, which aligns with the desire for independence from spectacles and potential cosmetic benefits, Younger adults and those with more frequent changes of spectacles are more likely to know about contact lenses.

Table 1

Gender distribution ofparticipants

Gender

Count

Percentage

Male

580

39%

Female

920

61%

Total

1500

100%

Table 2

Age distribution ofparticipants

Age group

n

Percentage %

18-24

1180

79

25-30

260

17

31-35

0

0

36-40

30

2

41-45

0

0

Above 45

30

2

Table 3

Participants’ information regarding CL use

Questionnaire

n

%

1. How much aware are you about the uses of contact lens?

o Not Aware at all

170

12%

o Slightly Aware

420

28%

o Moderately Aware

460

30%

o Extremely Aware

450

30%

2. According to you which are the purpose of the contact lens?

o Cosmetics (to change the eye colour)

90

6%

o Optical (Refractive correction)

270

18%

o Prosthetic (to hide the abnormality of an eye)

60

4%

o All of them

980

65%

o None

100

7%

3. Out of all usages of contact lens, which purpose you are wearing contact lens?

o Cosmetic purpose (to change the eye colour)

250

17%

o Optical purpose (Refractive correction)

450

30%

o Prosthetic purpose (to hide the abnormality of an eye)

70

46%

o All of them

230

15%

o None

490

33%

4. Which type of contact lens material do you use?

o Soft Hydrogel

220

15%

o RGP

170

11%

o Soft Silicone Hydrogel

450

30%

o I don't know

660

44%

5. Which type of contact lens design are you using?

o Spherical

460

31%

o Toric

200

13%

o Multifocal

30

2%

o Toric Multifocal

0

0%

o None

810

54%

6. Which company brand are you using?

o Bausch and Lomb

300

20%

o Acme

70

5%

o Cooper Vision

130

9%

o Johnson and Johnson

210

14%

o Other

160

11%

o None

630

42%

7. What type of contact lens solutions are you using?

o Bio True contact lens

290

19%

o Renu contact lens solutions

170

12%

o Opti-free contact lens solutions

80

5%

o All-in-one contact lens solutions

190

13%

o Other

150

10%

o None

620

41%

8. How often do you dispose your contact lens?

o Every Day

240

16%

o Once in a week

160

11%

o Once in a 15 Day

100

6%

o Once in a 30 Day

270

18%

o Once in a 180 Day

110

73%

o None

620

41%

9. Since how many days/months have you been using contact lenses?

o Less than 6 months ago

410

27%

o >24 months ago

90

6%

o 6-12 months ago

150

10%

o 12-24 months ago

130

9%

o Not in use

720

48%

10. How often do you wear your contact lenses?

o Never

610

40%

o Rarely

280

19%

o Sometimes

450

30%

o Often

80

5%

o Always

90

6%

11. Do you remove your contact lenses before sleeping?

o Not a wearer

310

21%

o Rarely

30

2%

o Sometimes

50

3%

o Always

110

8%

o Often

1000

67%

12. Do you remove your contact lenses before swimming or other activities?

o Not a wearer

340

23%

o Rarely

70

5%

o Sometimes

100

6%

o Always

130

9%

o Often

860

58%

13. Do you use contact lenses after the expiry date?

o Yes

200

13%

o No

1300

87%

14. How do you take care of your contact lenses?

o Using the provided solution

840

56%

o Wash with water

50

3%

o Always change overnight

120

8%

o Don’t clean regularly

90

6%

o With saliva

20

1%

o I Don't Know/None

380

25%

15. Are you aware of contact lens hygiene before wearing?

o Much Aware

640

42%

o Aware

420

28%

o Somewhat Aware

140

10%

o Little bit Aware

40

3%

o Not Aware

260

17%

16. Are you aware of possible contact lens side effects?

o Much Aware

480

32%

o Aware

460

30%

o Somewhat Aware

110

7%

o Little bit Aware

140

9%

o Not Aware

310

21%

17. Did you ever feel discomfort while using contact lenses?

o Very Discomfort

110

7%

o Discomfort

140

10%

o Neutral

380

26%

o Comfort

240

16%

o Very Comfort

120

8%

o None

510

34%

18. Symptoms faced due to contact lens?

o Discomfort

140

10%

o Redress

180

12%

o Pain

40

3%

o Watering

350

23%

o None

790

56%

19. Did you suffer eye problems due to contact lenses?

o Never

700

46%

o Rarely

340

23%

o Sometimes

300

20%

o Always

50

3%

o Often

110

8%

20. Did you suffer an allergic reaction due to contact lenses?

o Never

1000

67%

o Rarely

250

16%

o Sometimes

150

10%

o Often

40

3%

o Always

60

4%

21. For eye checkup related to contact lenses, whom do you consult?

o Optometrist

580

39%

o Ophthalmology

320

21%

o Home remedies

30

2%

o Optician

70

5%

o Ignore

80

5%

o None

420

28%

Additionally, the study found a female predominance (61%) in contact lens wearers, consistent with findings by Giri et al. (2012) 12 who reported 85% female users. Furthermore, the study by Abuallut et al. (2021) 13 in Saudi Arabia provides further evidence of the gender disparity in contact lens knowledge, with females exhibiting higher levels of understanding.

This study revealed mixed adherence to recommended hygiene protocols among contact lens users. While a significant portion of participants (79%) removed their lenses before sleeping and swimming, 21% engaged in behaviors that increased their risk of infection. Notably, only 56% consistently used contact lens solutions, underscoring the need for better education on proper lens care. These findings are consistent with Abuallut et al. (2021),13 who reported 94% solution usage, but also highlighted that some participants used water (2%) or did not use lenses at all (4%)​. Further, only 8% of participants regularly changed their overnight soaking solution, and 6% did not clean their lenses consistently. These statistics emphasize the need for targeted educational interventions to promote safe contact lens hygiene practices, aligning with Kumari et al. (2022),14 who stressed the importance of education to reduce complications.

The study identified a significant gap in contact lens awareness, with 40% of participants lacking basic knowledge about their use. This is slightly higher than the 34% unawareness reported by Shaik et al. (2021), 15 suggesting that contact lens education remains insufficient in many regions​. Regarding usage, only 5% of participants used lenses for therapeutic reasons, while 30% and 17% used them for vision correction and cosmetic purposes, respectively. This distribution may be influenced by regional demographics, socio-economic factors, or specific eye conditions prevalent in the study population.

Despite 80% of participants reporting no eye problems, a notable 21% experienced discomfort, including dryness, irritation, or watering while wearing lenses. Such discomfort likely contributed to the high dropout rate, with 28% of users discontinuing lens use within six months, consistent with the findings of Abuallut et al. (2021), 13 who reported similar issues with discomfort in 62% of users. These findings suggest that discomfort remains a significant barrier to long-term lens usage, further highlighting the importance of addressing fit, material, and care routines in contact lens education programs.

A significant portion of participants (43%) lacked awareness of the materials used in their contact lenses, with silicon hydrogel (30%), soft contact lenses (15%), and rigid gas permeable (RGP) lenses (12%) being the most popular choices. This lack of knowledge mirrors the findings of Albasheer et al. (2024), 11 who emphasized the need for informed decision-making in selecting contact lenses based on material properties. The study also revealed varying replacement schedules, with 16% using daily disposable lenses and 18% using monthly disposables. However, a smaller subset replaced their lenses every six months, a practice that deviates from manufacturer recommendations and could contribute to hygiene issues. This suggests that cost concerns or lack of awareness regarding replacement schedules are common, as noted by Ramos-Dávila et al. (2024), 16 who found poor compliance with recommended replacement routines in Northeast Mexico.

Our study found a significant dropout rate within the first year of contact lens use, with 28% of participants discontinuing use within six months. This is higher than the rate reported by Abuallut et al. (2021), 13 who found a much lower dropout rate of less than 6%​. The discrepancy highlights the need to investigate factors leading to early discontinuation, such as discomfort, improper lens handling, or lack of proper guidance.

When seeking help for contact lens-related issues, most participants consulted optometrists (39%), while a smaller group visited ophthalmologists (22%). This suggests that many users may not fully understand the roles of different eye care professionals. Clearer communication and education about which professional to consult for specific issues could improve help-seeking behavior and ensure appropriate management of contact lens complications.

As reported by several studies, barriers to contact lens use are prevalent across various populations. Common issues include a lack of interest, insufficient knowledge about lens care, and fear of side effects (Sadiq et al., 2023; 17 Albasheer et al., 2024. 11 Younger users in particular, who tend to have better awareness, may still struggle with compliance due to poor insertion/removal techniques and discomfort (Kumari et al., 2022). 14 Our findings corroborate these trends, suggesting that targeted educational interventions are crucial to improving hygiene practices and ensuring safer usage.

Given the significant gaps in hygiene practices, awareness, and understanding of contact lens materials and replacement schedules, it is clear that educational interventions are urgently needed. Similar to the recommendations made by Kumari et al. (2022), 14 educational programs should focus on proper care routines, lens handling, and the importance of compliance with replacement schedules to reduce complications and ensure safe usage.

In addition, the study identified a gap in understanding among participants regarding the role of different eye care professionals. Most sought help from optometrists for contact lens-related issues, but some were unsure whether to consult an optometrist or ophthalmologist, indicating a need for better education on the appropriate channels for seeking help.

Our study reveals that, despite moderate awareness of contact lens use, significant gaps in hygiene practices, materials knowledge, and compliance with recommended care persist. Educational initiatives are essential to improving these practices and should be tailored to address specific barriers such as cost concerns, fear of side effects, and lack of information. Special attention should be given to younger users and those new to contact lens use, as they are at a higher risk of discontinuing use prematurely due to discomfort or insufficient guidance.

Conclusion

The study reveals several key insights into the adoption and use of contact lenses in South Gujarat. While awareness of contact lenses is moderately high, significant gaps remain in the knowledge of lens materials, care practices, and potential side effects. Younger individuals and females are the primary users, driven by aesthetic preferences and a desire for freedom from spectacles. However, poor hygiene practices and a lack of awareness of complications pose significant risks to ocular health. The high dropout rate within six months of lens use further highlights the need for improved education and guidance to ensure users can enjoy the benefits of contact lenses without discomfort or complications.

This study emphasizes the need for targeted educational programs to address gaps in contact lens knowledge and hygiene practices. Eye care professionals should play a more active role in educating users about proper lens care, the risks of non-compliance, and the importance of regular follow-ups. By addressing these gaps, it may be possible to reduce the incidence of complications and improve the long-term adoption of contact lenses among the population.

Limitation

This study has several limitations that should be considered when interpreting the results. First, the cross-sectional design provides a snapshot of contact lens usage and practices at a single point in time, limiting the ability to assess changes in behaviour or knowledge over time. A longitudinal study could provide deeper insights into how knowledge and practices evolve with continued lens use.

Second, the sample was limited to South Gujarat, and thus the findings may not be generalizable to other regions of India or countries with different cultural, socioeconomic, or environmental contexts. Future research should aim to include a more diverse population to allow for broader generalization.

Lastly, the reliance on self-reported data introduces the potential for bias, as participants may have underreported poor hygiene practices or exaggerated their knowledge of contact lenses. Future studies could incorporate objective measures of compliance and knowledge to provide more accurate assessments.

Ethical approval

This study was conducted after taking approval from the Ethical Committee of the Institute (ref. No. BCOPT/357/2024).

Conflict of Interest

The authors report no conflicts of interest.

Source of Funding

None.

References

1 

FC Maduka-Okafor O Okoye I Ezegwui N C Oguego OI Okoye N Udeh Refractive Error and Visual Impairment Among School Children: Result of a South-Eastern Nigerian Regional SurveyClin Ophthalmol20211523455310.2147/OPTH.S298929

2 

R Pillay R Hansraj N Rampersad Historical Development, Applications and Advances in Materials Used in Spectacle Lenses and Contact LensesClin Optom (Auckl)2020121576710.2147/OPTO.S257081

3 

B Unnikrishnan S Hussain Pattern of use of contact lens among college students: a cross-sectional study in coastal KarnatakaIndian J Ophthalmol 20095764679

4 

JR Cope SA Collier MM Rao R Chalmers GL Mitchell K Richdale Contact Lens Wearer Demographics and Risk Behaviors for Contact Lens-Related Eye Infections--United StatesMMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep2014643286570

5 

N K Ibrahim H Seraj R Khan M Baabdullah L Reda Prevalence, habits and outcomes of using contact lenses among medical studentsPak J Med Sci2018346142934

6 

M Bashir AH Alghamdi AAE Ahmed SS Taishan WS Taishan MG Alghamdi The Prevalence of Contact Lens Wear and Improper Use Among Students of Al-Baha University, Saudi ArabiaOpen Ophthalmol J202410.2174/0118743641306553240313061238

7 

N Thite A Desiato L Shinde JS Wolffsohn SA Naroo J Santodomingo-Rubido Opportunities and Threats to Contact Lens Practice: A Global Survey PerspectiveCont Lens Anterior Eye202144610149610.1016/j.clae.2021.101496

8 

SV Waghmare S Jeria A Review of Contact Lens-Related Risk Factors and ComplicationsCureus20221410e3011810.7759/cureus.30118

9 

RP Maurya P Bhushan VP Singh MK Singh P Kumar RPS Bhatia Immunoglobulin concentration in tears of contact lens wearersJ Ophthalmic Vis Res2014933203

10 

CW Lievens KC Cilimberg A Moore Contact lens care tips for patients: an optometrist's perspectiveClin Optom (Auckl)201791132110.2147/OPTO.S139651

11 

O Albasheer IM Gosadi I Abuallut FF Khawaji AJ Almalki AK Muqanna Awareness and Hygiene Practices Among Contact Lens Wearers: A Population-Based Cross-Sectional SurveyCureus2024162e5472310.7759/cureus.54723

12 

PA Giri WM Chavan DB Phalke SV Bangal Knowledge and practice of contact lens wear and care among contact lens users medical students of rural medical collegeInt J Biol Med Res20123113857

13 

I Abuallut AA Hakami MI Alameer MO Shami NM Hakami AA Khawaji Awareness of the Practice and Use of Contact Lenses amongst Students of the Health Faculty at Jazan University during the COVID-19 PandemicJ Pharm Res Int20213359B37182

14 

K Sharma V Kumari A Malik M Dilkash D Gupta Knowledge and attitude on contact lens use among urban population of South Delhi- A questionnaire based studyIndian J Clin Exp Ophthalmol18109116

15 

RS Shaik BS Samanthula SK Pulivarthi PK Adusumilli Knowledge, Attitude and Practice of Contact Lens Users among South Indian PopulationIndian J Pharm Pract202114423944

16 

EM Ramos-Dávila RE Ruiz-Lozano K Gutierrez-Juarez CM Rusque-Lavalle PA Garza-Villarreal F Nacif-Lopéz Knowledge and compliance with contact lens care: A population-based study at a referral center in Northeast MexicoContact Lens Anterior Eye202447210212610.1016/j.clae.2024.102126

17 

M Sadiq F Ayub KN Ali Knowledge and barriers associated with contact lens use among spectacle wearersKhyber Med Univ J202315424753



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 25-08-2024

Accepted : 07-10-2024


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.ijooo.2024.027


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 129

PDF Downloaded: 8