Get Permission Sharat, Pani, Poornima Raj B, and Mohammed Sohail J: Eye on impact: An analysis of blunt ocular trauma cases at a tertiary eye care centre in South India


Introduction

Blunt ocular trauma is one of the most common eye injuries, particularly in younger individuals, and blunt objects account for approximately 30% of all such injuries. The primary cause is road traffic accidents, followed closely by occupational hazards.1

Blunt ocular trauma can result in either open or closed globe injuries. Closed globe injuries, where the outer structure of the eye remains intact, are classified into contusions, caused by blunt impact, and lamellar lacerations, which involve partial-thickness cuts. Open globe injuries, where the outer eye is breached, are categorized into lacerations, caused by sharp objects, and globe ruptures, which occur when the eye is severely damaged by blunt force. 2

Blunt ocular trauma can result from coup and countercoup forces, as well as anteroposterior compression or horizontal tissue expansion. 3 Coup injuries occur at the site of impact, resulting in conditions such as subconjunctival hemorrhage, corneal abrasions, and subretinal or choroidal hemorrhages. Contrecoup injuries, on the other hand, occur on the opposite side of the impact due to shock waves passing through the eye, as seen in conditions like commotio retinae. 4

Blunt ocular trauma can result in a broad spectrum of complications, ranging from minor injuries, such as subconjunctival hemorrhage, to severe, vision-threatening conditions like optic neuropathy, retinal detachment, and traumatic cataracts.

Materials and Methods

All cases of blunt eye injuries that sought care at the outpatient department of a tertiary eye care hospital from June 2024 to September 2024 were collected and analyzed from the medical records archive. A total of 417 patients were included in the study. Exclusion criteria comprised ocular injuries resulting from penetrating injuries, perforating injuries, chemical injuries, and thermal injuries. Data collected included demographic details, the mode of injury, and clinical presentation. Orbital imaging was obtained in cases with suspected orbital wall fractures. The ocular injuries were classified into open and closed globe injuries using the Birmingham Eye Trauma Terminology System. 5 The results were analyzed and presented in tabular form.

Results

Demographic characteristics

Table 1

Demographic profile of patients

Demographic variable

Numbers (N=417)

Percentage

Age group

<1 year

2

0.47%

1-10 years

41

9.83%

11 – 20 years

96

23.02%

21 – 30 years

101

24.22%

31 – 40 years

70

16.78%

41 – 50 years

57

13.66%

51 – 60 years

28

6.71%

61 – 70 years

15

3.59%

71 – 80 years

5

1.19%

81 – 90 years

2

0.47%

91 -100 years

0

0

Sex

Male

338

81.05%

Female

79

18.94%

Household

Urban

303

72.66%

Rural

114

27.33%

The study included 417 patients with blunt trauma injuries, ranging in age from newborns to 100 years, with an average age of 30. This suggests that the majority of the patients were in the young, productive age group (Table 1).

Eye injuries were notably more common in males, who accounted for 81% of cases (Table 1).

In our study, a higher proportion of patients came from urban households, with an incidence rate of 73%, compared to rural areas (Table 1).

Circumstances of injury

Table 2

Place of injury

Numbers (N =417)

Percentage

Place of injury

Road/Street

272

65.22%

Home

94

22.54%

Workplace

25

5.99%

Playground

26

6.23%

The majority of injuries occurred on the road or street (65.22%), followed by those that took place at home (22.54%) (Table 2).

Table 3

Modes of injury

Numbers (N =417)

Percentage

Modes of injury

Road traffic accident

150

35.97%

Assault

107

25.65%

Workplace

25

5.99%

Self fall

41

9.83%

Sports related

26

6.23%

Miscellaneous

68

16.30%

Among the 417 cases of blunt ocular trauma, road traffic accidents were the most common cause (35.97%), followed by assaults (25.65%) (Table 3).

Figure 1

Distribution of mode of injury

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/6fc09ea2-cfcb-4feb-9f75-ac7f7dfa44f9image1.png
Table 4

Agents of blunt ocular trauma

Numbers (N= 136)

Percentage

Agents of blunt ocular trauma

Hand

106

77.94%

Wood

41

30.14%

Metal

22

16.17%

Stone

16

11.76%

Plastic

12

8.82%

Cricket ball

21

16.17%

Shuttlecock

4

2.94%

Snooker stick

1

0.73%

Bull horn

3

2.20%

The most frequent agent of trauma was the hand (77.94%), followed by wood (30.14%) (Table 4).

Time of presentation

Table 5

Time of presentation

Numbers (N =417)

Percentage

Time of presentation

With in 1 day

395

94.72%

After week

5

1.19%

After 1 month

5

1.19%

After 1 year

8

1.91%

After 2 year

2

0.47%

After 20 year

2

0.47%

The majority (94.72%) of cases of blunt ocular trauma presented on the same day as the injury (Table 5). Out of the 417 cases, 285 were medico-legal cases (MLCs).

Pattern of injury

Table 6

Pattern of injury

Characteristics

Numbers (N =417)

Percentage

Laterality

Right eye

188

45.08%

Left eye

189

45.32%

Bilateral

49

11.75%

Type of injury

Open globe

17

4.07%

Closed globe

817

95.92%

Out of 417 blunt trauma cases, 45.32% involved the left eye, 45.08% involved the right eye, and 11.75% affected both eyes. Additionally, 17 patients (4.07%) had open globe injuries (Table 6).

Presentation

Table 7

Ocular structure involved

Ocular structure involved

Numbers (N=977 ocular structure)

Percentage

Orbit

36

3.68%

Extraocular muscle

12

1.22%

Adenexa

458

46.87%

Globe

16

1.63%

Conjunctiva

165

16.88%

Sclera

17

1.74%

Cornea

31

3.17%

Anterior chamber

42

4.29%

Iris and pupil

37

3.78%

Lens and IOL

18

1.84%

Vitreous

19

1.94%

Retina

78

7.98%

Optic Nerve

48

4.91%

Out of 977 eye structures affected by blunt trauma, the most commonly involved was the adnexa (46.87%), followed by the conjunctiva (16.88%) (Table 7).

Table 8

Presenting ocular findings

Characteristics

Numbers (N=834 eyes)

Percentage

Presenting Visual acuity

6/6 – 6/12

624

74.82%

6/18 – 6/60

58

6.95%

CF@3m – HM+ve

95

11.39%

PL positive

24

2.87%

PL negetive

25

2.99%

Couldn’t be assessed

8

0.95%

Orbital

Floor fracture

16

1.91%

Medial wall fracture

7

0.83%

Lateral wall fracture

9

1.07%

Roof fracture

1

0.11%

Retrobulbar haemorrhage

3

0.35%

Muscle movement restriction and limitation

Inferior rectus entrapment

2

0.23%

Oculomotor palsy

5

0.59%

Abducens palsy

5

0.59%

Adenexa

Periorbital edema

208

24.94%

Ecchymosis

160

19.18%

Lid laceration

57

6.83%

Lid abrasion

6

0.71%

Lid hematoma

4

0.47%

Preseptal cellulitis

5

0.59%

Brow laceration

6

0.71%

Mechanical Ptosis

7

0.83%

Canalicular tear

5

0.59%

Globe

Proptosis

7

0.83%

Enophthalmous

5

0.59%

Pthysis bulbi

4

0.47%

Conjunctiva

Conjunctival laceration

11

1.31%

Chemosis

5

0.59%

Subconjunctival haemorrhage

149

17.86%

Sclera

Globe rupture

13

1.55%

Sclerocorneal tear

4

0.47%

Cornea

Corneal abrasion

2

0.23%

Corneal tear

28

3.35%

Wound dehiscence of TPK

1

0.11%

Anterior chamber

Hyphema

16

1.91%

Uveitis

26

3.11%

Iris and pupil

Iris prolapse

12

1.43%

Iridodonesis

1

0.11%

Iridodialysis

6

17.64%

Traumatic mydriasis

18

2.15%

Lens and IOL

Traumatic cataract

3

0.35%

Phacodonesis

1

0.11%

Subluxated lens

10

1.19%

Subluxated IOL

4

0.47%

Vitreous

Vitreous Haemorrhage

19

2.27%

Retina

Retinal haemorrhage

5

0.59%

Berlin edema

32

3.83% 1.43%

Commotio retina

12

Macular hole

4

0.47%

Retinal detachment

25

2.99%

Optic nerve

Traumatic optic neuropathy

48

5.75%

In 74.82% of patients, vision was better than 6/12, while 2.99% presented with no perception of light. Periorbital edema was the most common finding, occurring in 24.94% of cases (Table 8).

Figure 2

A: Eyelid edema, ecchymosis, and brow laceration due to a dumbbell injury in the gym; B: Repaired laceration.

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/6fc09ea2-cfcb-4feb-9f75-ac7f7dfa44f9image2.png
Figure 3

A: Eye lid laceration due to bull horn injury; B: Repaired laceration

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/6fc09ea2-cfcb-4feb-9f75-ac7f7dfa44f9image3.png
Figure 4

A: Corneal tear with Iris incarceration following blunt trauma, B: Repaired corneal tear

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/6fc09ea2-cfcb-4feb-9f75-ac7f7dfa44f9image4.png

Figure 5

A: Globe rupture with vitreous haemorrhage following blunt trauma; B: Extent of scleral tear below Superior rectus insertion; C: Repaired scleral tear

https://typeset-prod-media-server.s3.amazonaws.com/article_uploads/bb020279-6e57-48cf-b9e7-8bdfc4a7e876/image/4d91d4b8-d644-41f2-831c-e1b9bee3505a-uimage.png

Mangement

Surgical procedures were performed on 17.2% of the affected eyes, including both minor outpatient operations and major surgeries that required hospitalization.

Discussion

Blunt objects are the most common cause of mechanical ocular trauma. In this study, it was observed that the majority of injuries (24.22%) occur among productive young people aged 21 to 30 years, with males (81%) more commonly sustaining blunt ocular trauma compared to females (19%). This aligns with the findings of Nayagam et al.6 This male predominance appears to be linked to outdoor activities, engagement in hazardous recreational activities and sports, risk-taking behaviors, alcohol consumption, and personal conflicts.

The present study revealed a higher prevalence of blunt ocular trauma in the urban population (73%) compared to the rural population (27%), consistent with the findings of Sujatha et al.7 who reported that 78% of blunt trauma occurred in the urban population.

In the current study, the most common place of injury was the street or road (65.22%), followed by the home (22.54%), workplace (5.99%), and playground (6.23%). This is consistent with the findings of the study by Maurya et al.8

In this study, the most common cause of blunt ocular trauma was road traffic accidents (35.97%), which aligns with the findings of Pai et al.9

The majority of ocular blunt trauma cases (94.72%) were presented on the same day as the injury, while 5.28% of cases were presented late, more than a week after the incident. This is consistent with the findings of Mishra et al.10

The most frequent cause of trauma was the hand (77.94%), followed by wood (30.14%). In contrast, wood was identified as the most common agent in the study conducted by Maurya et al.,6 while metallic objects were the most common in the study by Syal et al.11

The majority of victims (90.4%) experienced unilateral blunt ocular trauma, with a predominance of left eye involvement (45.32%). In contrast, only 11.75% had bilateral involvement, which aligns with the findings of Maurya et al.12, 13

Most injuries were closed globe injuries (95.93%), while 4.07% were open globe injuries. This is consistent with the study by Marudhamuthu et al.,14 which reported a closed globe injury rate of 95.3%.

The most commonly affected ocular structure was the adnexa (46.87%), followed by the conjunctiva (16.88%). Periorbital edema was the most frequent finding, observed in 24.94% of cases.

Conclusion

Ocular trauma is a significant cause of avoidable, primarily monocular visual morbidity (visual impairment and blindness), with more than half of blinding injuries now occurring at home.15 Our study concludes that blunt trauma is the most common ocular injury, primarily caused by road traffic accidents, physical assaults, and sports-related injuries, with young adult males being the most vulnerable. Road traffic accidents are mainly due to skids and falls. Sports-related injuries are more prevalent among children and young adults.16

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None

References

1 

J Kumar S Tolia Ocular Blunt Trauma In Bundelkhand Region: A Retrospective Study In Bundelkhand RegionInt J Adv Res20248485210.21474/IJAR01/18462

2 

D Mutie N Mwangi Assessing an eye injury patientCommunity Eye Health20152891468

3 

AS Maiya AM Dharmesh R Jayaram Clinical profile of ocular blunt trauma in a rural hospitalJ Clin Ophthalmol Res20186137

4 

JR Wolter Coup-contrecoup mechanism of ocular injuriesAm J Ophthalmol1963567859610.1016/0002-9394(63)92943-x

5 

M Dogramaci SK Erdur F Senturk Standardized Classification of Mechanical Ocular Injuries: Efficacy and ShortfallsBeyoglu Eye J20216323642

6 

G Nayagam M Raman A Anuradha S Sheela N Chakravarthy Assessment of visual prognosis using ocular trauma score in open globe injury at a tertiary care centreTNOA J Ophthalmic Sci Res2020581913

7 

MA Sujatha A Nazlin S Prakash S Nousheen Prevalence of Visual Impairment after Blunt Ocular Trauma in a Tertiary HospitalInt J Sci Stud201534369

8 

A Singh RP Maurya VP Singh S Gautam A Kumar CP Mishra Study of epidemiology, clinical profile, visual outcome and prognostic factors of blunt ocular trauma in a teaching hospitalIndian J Clin Exp Ophthalmol20228445867

9 

SG Pai S J Karnath S D'Souza L Dudeja A clinical study of blunt trauma in a Tertiary care centreOnline J Health Allied Sci201312210

10 

A Mishra AK Verma VK Baranwal S Aggarwal N Bhargava JK Parihar The pattern and visual outcomes of ocular trauma in a large zonal hospital in a non-operational role A 36 months retrospective analysisJ Clin Ophthalmol Res2014231414

11 

E Syal M Dhawan SP Singh To study the epidemiological and clinical profile of ocular trauma at a tertiary health-care facilityDelta J Ophthalmol201819425967

12 

RP Maurya VP Singh SMU Kadir JK Das SK Bosak MK Prajapat The study of simultaneous bilateral ocular trauma in Northern India: clinical presentation, epidemiology and patterns of injuryInt Ophthalmol20214241193203

13 

RP Maurya Ocular trauma during COVID- 19 crisis: Trends and managementIndian J Clin Exp Ophthalmol2020644789

14 

E Marudhamuthu N Sivakumar T Kumaravel Studyofocularinjuries in road traffic accident patientsJ Eval Med Sci2017641321922

15 

P Desai CJ Macewen P Baines DC Minassian Incidence of cases of ocular trauma admitted to hospital and incidence of blinding outcomeBr J Ophthalmol1996805926

16 

A Kaur A Agrawal Paediatric Ocular TraumaCurr Sci2005891436



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 08-09-2024

Accepted : 07-10-2024


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/ 10.18231/j.ijooo.2024.025


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 311

PDF Downloaded: 33